A recent trip to New York City landed me in the middle of a divine convergence: record-breaking heat and the repopularization of frozen yogurt.

I’d seen the signs all over my Instagram feed leading up to my visit, that it would be hotter than ever while Taylor Swift got married inside of an air-conditioned Madison Square Garden while commoners like myself could get cool from the inside out eating frozen yogurt. The likes of the Wall Street Journal and New York Times Magazine were covering the resurgence, with articles like “Frozen Yogurt Is Back” and “Why Is Everyone Waiting Hours for Frozen Yogurt?” I was willing to wait in line to see for myself.

But it turned out people in New York respond to 100°+ heat similarly to New Mexicans, by staying inside. So when I arrived at Culture: An American Yogurt Company in Greenwich Village, where it was already climbing past 97° at 10 am, I walked right into a mostly empty store whose occupants consisted of myself, the employees, and a couple of women who’d just gotten out of a fancy sculpt class across the street. I built my own cup of original tart yogurt topped with strawberries, kiwi, raspberry drizzle, and toasted coconut flakes. It was $16, competitive pricing among the many froyo spots who had a summer 2026 New York minute, like Myka Greek Frozen Yogurt and Madison Fare.

Frozen yogurt has been cool three distinct times in US history. 

The first was in the 1980s era of low-fat diet culture, when TCBY still stood for “This Can’t Be Yogurt!” It was yogurt parading as “healthy ice cream,” and TCBY’s biggest hit was their White Chocolate Mousse flavor. But no one can hide from themselves forever, and when frozen yogurt came back into popularity in the early 2000s, it reached self-actualization by leaning into its natural tartness. This was the Fruity Pebbles era of froyo: The yogurt was remarkably yogurt, but you were defined by the self-serve toppings selected from a buffet of cookie dough balls, strawberries, mini M&M’s, mochi, sugary cereal, peanut butter drops, coconut flakes, cheesecake bites, and so many drizzles. 

And now, it has been re-reinvented to meet the modern moment, when a treat is rarely just a treat. In this case, it’s also touted as a means to achieve glowing skin, hormone regulation, and a peaceful gut biome. While health care remains unaffordable, maybe this singular cup of yogurt will fix you. Pairing nicely with those probiotics and protein gains are imported toppings like fennel pollen, pistachio drizzle, and extra-virgin olive oil, all of which have joined the ranks of rainbow sprinkles as standard toppings. Overall luxurious and purportedly balanced enrichment for the mind, body, and soul.

When I returned from my trip, my recaps to friends always included how I didn’t have to wait in line for the new trendy food thing, how the frozen yogurt was expensive but ultimately delicious, refreshing, and there was an outlet where I could charge my phone before resuming my day as an NYC tourist. This was also when I reminded my fellow New Mexicans that we have an excellent, locally owned business serving frozen yogurt and more in Nob Hill: Olo Dessert Studio. And while Olo can get busy, there’s approximately zero chance you’ll ever have to wait hours in line. 

“Froyo never left,” said Camilla Dominguez when I sat down with her and Olo manager, Hannah Iracheta, at the Route 66 storefront. I was prodding them about whether they had noticed this resurgence elsewhere, and their nonchalance reminded me that whatever food trends are happening in New York or San Francisco are sort of none of New Mexico’s business. 

Olo has been dispensing a steady-flowing stream of frozen yogurt and soft sorbets since 2010. Founded by tenth-generation New Mexican Paula Pope, the business is now run by the Dominguez family with Camilla at the helm. Much like other tastemakers of the froyosphere, Pope was interested in the dessert’s health factor. Nowadays, Dominguez and team carry forth Pope’s vision with more mindfulness around allergens and the general aversions to dairy and gluten that’ve risen over the last decade. Since Dominguez has taken over, they’ve ridden the waves of COVID, the prolonged implementation of the ART bus route, and rising expenses. But Dominguez says that staying flexible as a businesswoman has allowed them to survive. 

“We’ve been able to move with changes rather than resist them,” said Dominguez as I gestured outside to Central, where I’ve lost count of how many businesses I’ve seen close or move over the last two years I’ve lived in Nob Hill. It’s not that Dominguez seems unfazed by the turmoil; she just has faith in her staff and community that Olo is here to stay. 

“I like the community,” said Iracheta. “I love when people come in here and realize there’s actually something for everyone. They don’t have to move from one spot to the next, they can come here and hang out for a while and have a good time.” Iracheta loves to see new people find Olo. Even though the storefront has been in business for seventeen years, Iracheta says people still walk in asking if they are at a Menchie’s. Not quite. 

“Everybody that comes in here is cherished to us, whether it’s our staff, whether it’s somebody who lives down the street, or whether it’s a traveler,” said Dominguez before she and Iracheta started listing their favorite regulars and their orders: Ben’s chocolate vanilla swirl, Jimmy’s white chocolate, Michael’s hot tea (Olo has a full-service espresso bar), and Luca and Noemi, a mother-baby duo who come in for tiny cups of toppings. “If you just want to get toppings, like a bucket of popping pearls, you can!” said Dominguez. Popping pearls, which are available in mango and strawberry, are Olo’s fastest-selling topping. 

I lean toward the fruity options at Olo. My typical order includes a base of their Taos Original Tart Yogurt and Sandia-Means-Watermelon sorbet topped with strawberries, kiwi, mango popping pearls, walnuts, and Tajín. Sweet, sour, and creamy, with lots of texture. Should I ever want to stray, there are plenty more fun flavors with equally fun names to choose from, like Belen Biscochito, Capulin Cake Batter, Peñasco Pineapple, and Atomic Eggnog, to name a few. 

Whether frozen yogurt trends ebb and flow elsewhere, Olo has no plans of going anywhere. They are really excited for their annual hot chocolate bar at the Nob Hill Twinkle Light Parade on Saturday, December 5. If you have any requests for flavors at the shop, Dominguez says they are always open to suggestions. 

📍3339 Central NE, Ste C3, Albuquerque, 505-750-4656

Nina Katz
+ more posts

Nina Katz is a food writer living in Albuquerque. They would like to see Froyo come back in a big way.